Beets on conveyor

Chopped sugar beet makes its way along a conveyor belt on the way to being processed. © Avatar_023/iStock/Getty Images Plus

Beets on conveyor

Chopped sugar beet makes its way along a conveyor belt on the way to being processed. © Avatar_023/iStock/Getty Images Plus

This month’s Processing column continues the theme of “How is it processed?” with a focus on sugar. In addition to exploring the history, market, and consumption of sugar, the column will outline the steps involved in processing and production.

History, Market, and Consumption

Sugar is derived from two main plant sources: sugar cane and sugar beets. As one of the oldest commodities in the world, it was first domesticated around 8000 B.C. by indigenous people in New Guinea. Because of its value, sugar was often put under lock and key in sugar safes. In 1751, the first U.S. sugar cane was planted in Louisiana, marking the beginning of the U.S. sugar industry, which today provides 142,000 jobs in 22 states.

Sugar is produced in over 120 countries; nearly 80% of sugar comes from sugar cane, with the remainder derived from sugar beets. In the United States, 55% of sugar production comes from sugar beets and 45% from sugar cane.

According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) Foreign Agricultural Service, global sugar production is estimated to reach 188 million metric tons this year, an increase of 22 million tons from last year. Brazil (39.5 million tons) is currently the largest producer of sugar, followed by India (33.7 million tons) and the European Union (17.7 million tons). The United States is forecast to produce 8.2 million tons of sugar this year.

Sugar is produced in over 120 countries; nearly 80% of sugar comes from sugar cane, with the remainder derived from sugar beets.

Over the past 20 years, sugar consumption in the United States has declined. According to the Sugar Association, annual sugar consumption was 89.6 pounds/person in 1999; in 2016 it was 77.1 pounds/person, the equivalent of about 16 teaspoons/day.

Sugar comes in a wide variety of forms. The most common is granulated sugar, also called table sugar, which is the most refined form. Granulated sugar with larger crystals is called coarse sugar; with smaller crystals, it is called superfine sugar. Pearl sugar is composed of conglomerates of sugar particles. Brown sugars in various color ranges are defined by the amount of molasses present within them; they range from bright yellow to dark brown. Specialty sugar types include powdered sugar (contains cornstarch), demerara-style sugar (light brown sugar with large crystals coated with molasses), muscovado sugar (stickier, coarse brown sugar produced at an early stage of refining), and turbinado-style sugar (partially purified, semi-refined brown sugar that is also called Sugar in the Raw. True raw sugar refers to partially purified sugar that is soft and brown and contains impurities.

Sugar Processing

• Harvesting. Sugar cane and sugar beets are typically harvested from fields mechanically. The harvested plant materials are frequently sieved to remove dirt and rocks before being loaded onto trucks and taken to the factory for processing.

Sugar Beets Railroad Cars

Railway bins loaded with raw sugar cane wait in a holding yard before proceeding to the mill for crushing and processing. © BeyondImages/iStock/Getty Images Plus

Sugar Beets Railroad Cars

Railway bins loaded with raw sugar cane wait in a holding yard before proceeding to the mill for crushing and processing. © BeyondImages/iStock/Getty Images Plus

Washing and Initial Preparation. As soon as the sugar cane or sugar beets arrive at the factory, they are washed extensively. Washing can occur on belts that are sprayed with water or in flues that are full of water. Rotating drums are often used as washing stations. Water is sprayed into the drum and product rotates within the drum, rubbing against itself to remove dirt. After washing, the sugar cane or sugar beets are conveyed into the factory using screws or belts. The sugar cane is crushed using swing-hammer shredders or heavily grooved crusher rollers. Sugar beets are cut using slicing machines, which tear them into strips smaller than French fries, called cossettes. The cossettes are soaked in hot water tanks, while the crushed sugar cane is sprayed with hot water. Both processes serve to swell the plant cells in preparation for extraction.

• Juice Extraction. The sugar cossettes are pumped into the bottom of 10- to 20-meter-tall tanks. A rotating shaft in the center transports the sugar beet strips upwards against the downward flow of water as the sugar is extracted. For sugar cane, milling is used to extract the juice. A series of five mills compresses the sugar cane fibers and separates the juice from the bagasse, which can be used later as a fuel source. The initial juice is dark green in color and is acidic and turbid. The juice is collected in large vats and the sugar concentration is measured.

• Purification of Juice. Tall towers, 10 to 20 meters high, are used to purify and lighten the color of the cane juice. The juice is introduced at the top of the tower and sulfur dioxide vapor is introduced at the bottom. The sulfur dioxide rises up through the tower in a process called sulfitation. Gas is added at 120 to 200 pounds per million pounds of juice. Carbonation or alkalization is used to further separate the soluble non-sugar materials from the sugar juice. Carbonation employs calcium carbonate or calcium sulfite to aid in precipitation. The juice is heated to denature the protein content and is then mixed with a slurry of calcium hydroxide, called milk of lime. Carbon dioxide gas bubbles can also be introduced in this step to lower the alkalinity and precipitate the carbonation sludge, which is filtered to purify the juice.

The clarification process typically takes several hours. At the end, the sludge is removed from the bottom of the tank and the juice is removed from the top. Secondary filtration is used to extract any remaining sugar from the sludge. This produces a material called mud, which can be used later to fertilize fields.

The clarified juice is then boiled in a series of vacuum evaporators until it reaches a concentration of 50%–65% sugar. Each subsequent evaporator in the series has a higher vacuum pressure than the previous evaporator, resulting in the sugar syrup boiling at progressively lower temperatures as it moves through the process. Sediment is skimmed off the top of the evaporators using paddle skimmers, producing a thick, nearly colorless sugar syrup.

• Crystallization. During the next step in the manufacturing process, a single-stage vacuum pan is used to evaporate the syrup until it is saturated with sugar crystals, which are formed through a process called seeding. A milky solution of pure sucrose suspended in alcohol and glycerin is the seed that is slowly added to the syrup. The small grains of sugar present in the solution serve as nuclei, helping to draw out the sugar in solution and convert it into crystals. As the mixture is boiled in a vacuum pan, water evaporates and sugar crystals continue to grow into a paste called massecuite, a dense mixture of syrup and sugar crystals. This mixture is then transferred into a large container called a crystallizer, where the massecuite is slowly stirred and cooled, continuing the crystallization process.

• Centrifugation. To separate the massecuite into sugar crystals and molasses, the massecuite is added to a high-speed centrifuge. The centrifuge, which rotates at 1,000 to 2,800 revolutions per minute, contains a perforated metal cylindrical basket. During centrifugation, the molasses passes out of the lined centrifuge basket and is drawn to the outside of the centrifuge where it is removed and sent to storage tanks. The sugar is retained in the lined centrifuge basket. Spring water is used to wash the crystals as they are centrifuged.

• Drying and Packaging. The damp sugar crystals are dried in large, hot air dryers, reaching a moisture content of as low as 0.02%. Next, the sugar is gently tumbled through heated air in a granulator. The dried crystals are then separated into different sizes through vibrating screens and placed into storage bins. Finally, the sugar is packaged for the consumer.

The Future of Sugar

Sugar is a versatile and critical food ingredient with a wide range of benefits. Not only does it provide foods with sweetness and flavor, it also adds aroma, color, texture, and shelf-life stability. The role sugar plays in continuing to make our lives sweeter is assured.

REFERENCES

How Products Are Made. “Sugar.” http://www.madehow.com/Volume-1/Sugar.html.

Southern Minnesota Beet Sugar Cooperative. “Sulfitation.” https://www.smbsc.com/OurSugar/SugarProcess/Sulfitation.aspx.

The Sugar Association. “Getting to Know Nature’s Oldest Sweetener.” http://www.sugar.org/sugar.

USDA. 2020. Sugar: World Markets and Trade. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Foreign Agricultural Service.

About the Author

Tara McHugh, Contributing Editor, Processing column
tara.mchugh@ars.usda.gov
Tara McHugh